leonid-radvinsky
The statement “The adult content creators upset after Pornhub exits France” is confirmed by multiple sources reporting on Pornhub’s decision to suspend access in France on June 4, 2025, in response to a new age-verification law. Adult content creators expressed significant distress over the move, citing impacts on their livelihoods, lack of consultation, and broader implications for their industry. Below, I’ll explain the context, reasons for their upset, and key perspectives based on available information.
Confirmation and Context
Pornhub, along with sister sites YouPorn and RedTube, owned by Aylo, blocked access to its platforms in France, its second-largest market after the U.S., to protest a French law requiring stricter age verification to protect minors from accessing adult content. The law, part of the SREN legislation passed in 2023, mandates that adult websites verify users’ ages using methods like credit card details or government-issued IDs, with a compliance deadline of June 7, 2025. Aylo argued that the law compromises user privacy and is ineffective, opting to suspend operations rather than comply.
This decision directly affected adult content creators in France, who rely on Pornhub for visibility and income. Reports, particularly from Le Monde, detailed creators’ feelings of devastation, anxiety, and weariness, as they were not consulted by either Pornhub or the French government regarding the new legal framework.
Reasons for Creators’ Upset
- Loss of Livelihood and Visibility:
- Creators depend on Pornhub as a primary platform for distributing content and earning income through ad revenue, subscriptions, or fan site traffic. The suspension in France, a major market with 7 million daily visitors, significantly reduced their audience and revenue potential.
- Although verified creators can still upload content and monetize views from outside France, the loss of domestic traffic is a major blow. One creator, Carmina, a director and actress in alternative pornography, emphasized the platform’s role as “my livelihood” and “my showcase.”
- The sudden block left creators feeling their industry was “gutted,” with fears of long-term financial instability.
- Lack of Consultation:
- Creators expressed frustration that neither Aylo nor the French government involved them in discussions about the age-verification law. This exclusion left them feeling sidelined in decisions directly impacting their work.
- Le Monde reported creators’ regret over being ignored, despite their stake in the platform’s operations and their agreement on the need to protect minors from adult content.
- Privacy and Regulatory Concerns:
- While creators support preventing minors from accessing their content, they share Aylo’s concerns about the law’s privacy implications. The requirement to collect sensitive user data (e.g., IDs or credit card details) raises risks of hacks or leaks, which could indirectly affect creators’ trust in the platform.
- Creators also face uncertainty about how to adapt to a fragmented regulatory landscape, as similar age-verification laws are emerging globally, including in 19 U.S. states and the EU.
- Mixed Industry Perspectives:
- Some former adult industry figures, like Céline Tran and Nikita Bellucci, praised Pornhub’s suspension on BFM-TV, citing child protection, but active creators felt betrayed by these views, highlighting a divide. Current creators criticized these ex-stars as “ladder pullers” who benefited from the industry but now support restrictive laws after achieving success.
- This tension underscores creators’ sense of being caught between regulatory pressures and shifting public sentiment without adequate representation.
Broader Implications
- Economic Impact: France’s exit represents a significant revenue loss for Aylo, which may reduce resources for creators globally. However, creators can still earn from international views, and Pornhub has encouraged strategies like using Shorties or TrafficJunky ads to grow audiences elsewhere.
- Workarounds and VPN Surge: A 1,000% spike in Proton VPN signups within 30 minutes of the block suggests users are bypassing restrictions, but this doesn’t fully restore creators’ domestic audience or address their concerns.
- Global Trend: The situation in France reflects a broader push for age-verification laws, with the EU investigating Pornhub and other platforms for child safety compliance. Creators face an uncertain future as more regions adopt similar measures, potentially forcing platforms to geoblock or overhaul operations.
Critical Perspective
While the French law aims to protect minors—a goal creators support—its implementation raises questions about efficacy and fairness. VPN usage undermines enforcement, and the burden on adult sites rather than device manufacturers (e.g., Apple, Google) seems inconsistent, as Aylo argues. The lack of creator input highlights a disconnect in policymaking, where those most affected are excluded. Moreover, the celebratory tone of officials like Aurore Bergé, who said “Good!” to Pornhub’s exit, overlooks the economic hardship for creators who are not opposed to child protection but seek practical solutions.
Conclusion
Adult content creators in France are upset due to Pornhub’s exit on June 4, 2025, which threatens their income, visibility, and professional stability. Their distress stems from financial losses, exclusion from policy discussions, and concerns about privacy-invasive regulations. While they agree on protecting minors, they feel caught in a poorly executed regulatory clash, with their voices ignored. The situation underscores broader challenges in balancing child safety, privacy, and the rights of adult industry workers in an increasingly regulated digital landscape.
About the Author
